Replicating Elastic Plates solutions with Shell Solver

Numerical methods and mathematical models of Elmer
Post Reply
CrocoDuck
Posts: 45
Joined: 12 May 2016, 13:15
Antispam: Yes

Replicating Elastic Plates solutions with Shell Solver

Post by CrocoDuck » 08 Aug 2016, 14:20

Hi there, your favourite boring duck is back!

So, I had some success running a model of an Elastic Plate using, indeed, the Smitc solver.

However, I will need to solve for plates which do not rest on the XY plane. In fact, I will need to solve elastic models of Shells (like this).

In order to gain some confidence that the (undocumented) ShellSolver does what I want, I am trying to solve the Elastic Plate eigenproblem above with the ShellSolver. However, the results given by the ShellSolver are very different:

SmitcSolver:

Code: Select all

EigenSolve: Computed 400 Eigen Values
EigenSolve: --------------------------------
EigenSolve: 1:    2.236747E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 2:    8.698813E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 3:    2.053312E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 4:    2.888364E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 5:    3.580030E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 6:    7.066704E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 7:    7.692391E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 8:    9.202957E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 9:    1.219866E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 10:    1.392753E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 11:    1.726293E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 12:    1.813470E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 13:    2.614479E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 14:    2.783288E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 15:    2.842676E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 16:    3.288832E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 17:    3.415070E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 18:    4.225758E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 19:    4.505997E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 20:    4.627128E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 21:    5.736028E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 22:    6.147907E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 23:    6.658875E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 24:    7.058871E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 25:    7.429704E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 26:    7.743232E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 27:    8.018399E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 28:    8.808919E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 29:    1.029479E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 30:    1.081447E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 31:    1.093897E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 32:    1.132879E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 33:    1.233295E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 34:    1.366213E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 35:    1.401893E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 36:    1.475828E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 37:    1.598090E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 38:    1.614304E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 39:    1.628375E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 40:    1.667922E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 41:    1.830493E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 42:    1.882460E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 43:    1.956826E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 44:    2.234532E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 45:    2.347432E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 46:    2.362572E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 47:    2.411203E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 48:    2.460095E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 49:    2.516038E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 50:    2.664203E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 51:    2.770511E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 52:    2.910698E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 53:    2.920396E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 54:    3.085206E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 55:    3.181095E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 56:    3.299357E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 57:    3.329368E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 58:    3.579308E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 59:    3.632925E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 60:    3.820833E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 61:    3.952120E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 62:    4.183371E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 63:    4.198865E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 64:    4.278069E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 65:    4.470842E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 66:    4.510559E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 67:    4.566291E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 68:    4.615053E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 69:    4.801342E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 70:    5.046335E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 71:    5.284353E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 72:    5.400428E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 73:    5.466604E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 74:    5.487629E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 75:    5.630463E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 76:    5.754219E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 77:    5.939943E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 78:    6.264908E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 79:    6.527376E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 80:    6.793615E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 81:    6.840415E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 82:    6.928183E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 83:    7.084213E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 84:    7.086336E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 85:    7.245317E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 86:    7.440554E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 87:    7.444161E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 88:    7.498916E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 89:    7.877753E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 90:    7.935185E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 91:    8.100504E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 92:    8.346011E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 93:    8.908620E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 94:    9.095188E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 95:    9.102715E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 96:    9.228997E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 97:    9.296956E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 98:    9.672450E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 99:    9.696575E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 100:    9.893731E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 101:    9.949020E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 102:    1.041811E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 103:    1.071865E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 104:    1.089144E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 105:    1.093036E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 106:    1.122801E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 107:    1.125355E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 108:    1.136471E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 109:    1.158358E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 110:    1.179513E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 111:    1.196277E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 112:    1.223151E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 113:    1.246959E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 114:    1.286033E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 115:    1.291401E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 116:    1.291628E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 117:    1.294245E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 118:    1.409825E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 119:    1.412113E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 120:    1.419112E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 121:    1.436374E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 122:    1.460079E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 123:    1.481232E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 124:    1.525365E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 125:    1.535279E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 126:    1.561759E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 127:    1.574467E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 128:    1.581770E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 129:    1.584080E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 130:    1.623123E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 131:    1.659591E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 132:    1.711446E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 133:    1.715954E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 134:    1.743683E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 135:    1.744706E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 136:    1.763707E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 137:    1.793371E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 138:    1.823456E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 139:    1.826905E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 140:    1.828454E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 141:    1.976587E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 142:    1.989488E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 143:    1.991484E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 144:    1.995765E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 145:    2.014605E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 146:    2.102327E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 147:    2.111606E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 148:    2.139312E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 149:    2.159305E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 150:    2.161464E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 151:    2.172898E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 152:    2.205001E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 153:    2.252886E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 154:    2.257147E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 155:    2.262529E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 156:    2.277882E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 157:    2.326767E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 158:    2.380447E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 159:    2.382441E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 160:    2.472324E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 161:    2.520234E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 162:    2.531664E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 163:    2.545178E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 164:    2.580800E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 165:    2.582634E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 166:    2.607363E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 167:    2.630059E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 168:    2.644278E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 169:    2.693880E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 170:    2.715803E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 171:    2.770024E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 172:    2.798091E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 173:    2.907216E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 174:    2.955851E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 175:    2.957972E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 176:    2.980266E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 177:    3.031383E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 178:    3.042451E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 179:    3.054095E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 180:    3.058607E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 181:    3.116734E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 182:    3.142919E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 183:    3.157130E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 184:    3.163298E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 185:    3.170137E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 186:    3.239090E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 187:    3.252617E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 188:    3.320765E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 189:    3.372239E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 190:    3.395266E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 191:    3.400174E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 192:    3.439560E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 193:    3.466816E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 194:    3.601605E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 195:    3.615016E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 196:    3.647374E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 197:    3.698289E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 198:    3.710254E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 199:    3.745387E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 200:    3.798888E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 201:    3.822714E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 202:    3.847959E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 203:    3.860510E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 204:    3.901901E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 205:    3.981835E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 206:    4.013640E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 207:    4.073216E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 208:    4.074153E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 209:    4.142224E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 210:    4.172202E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 211:    4.188777E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 212:    4.236110E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 213:    4.237008E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 214:    4.258530E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 215:    4.308507E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 216:    4.313891E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 217:    4.335166E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 218:    4.486657E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 219:    4.487254E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 220:    4.489186E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 221:    4.499689E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 222:    4.542107E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 223:    4.694585E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 224:    4.715652E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 225:    4.731370E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 226:    4.800893E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 227:    4.829017E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 228:    4.887358E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 229:    4.893800E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 230:    5.000546E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 231:    5.009626E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 232:    5.014144E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 233:    5.056992E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 234:    5.127533E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 235:    5.157000E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 236:    5.265457E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 237:    5.298337E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 238:    5.349879E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 239:    5.361896E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 240:    5.367053E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 241:    5.384848E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 242:    5.399603E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 243:    5.447639E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 244:    5.480631E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 245:    5.643272E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 246:    5.659710E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 247:    5.743798E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 248:    5.806530E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 249:    5.812488E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 250:    5.822966E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 251:    5.849796E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 252:    5.856087E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 253:    5.893589E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 254:    5.900306E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 255:    5.922271E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 256:    6.037495E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 257:    6.057163E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 258:    6.120771E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 259:    6.185661E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 260:    6.201059E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 261:    6.381717E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 262:    6.416346E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 263:    6.441905E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 264:    6.514808E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 265:    6.609864E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 266:    6.727078E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 267:    6.728053E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 268:    6.766888E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 269:    6.794376E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 270:    6.819883E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 271:    6.823310E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 272:    6.871365E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 273:    6.894682E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 274:    6.928150E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 275:    6.949317E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 276:    7.022176E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 277:    7.074279E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 278:    7.078414E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 279:    7.202012E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 280:    7.213069E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 281:    7.263772E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 282:    7.267793E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 283:    7.330240E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 284:    7.420896E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 285:    7.502283E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 286:    7.505457E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 287:    7.593594E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 288:    7.765378E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 289:    7.780568E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 290:    7.783501E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 291:    7.805439E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 292:    7.920972E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 293:    7.970576E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 294:    8.003459E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 295:    8.015057E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 296:    8.031546E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 297:    8.113869E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 298:    8.168225E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 299:    8.207975E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 300:    8.252598E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 301:    8.337048E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 302:    8.372622E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 303:    8.505660E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 304:    8.597376E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 305:    8.772852E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 306:    8.775148E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 307:    8.788929E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 308:    8.864475E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 309:    8.895424E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 310:    8.898749E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 311:    8.931970E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 312:    8.938422E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 313:    9.009210E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 314:    9.038158E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 315:    9.045097E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 316:    9.097458E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 317:    9.166614E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 318:    9.219533E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 319:    9.369243E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 320:    9.468750E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 321:    9.492035E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 322:    9.496894E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 323:    9.584024E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 324:    9.659728E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 325:    9.662327E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 326:    9.673957E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 327:    9.804732E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 328:    9.830495E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 329:    9.896542E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 330:    9.984029E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 331:    1.015235E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 332:    1.021045E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 333:    1.023666E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 334:    1.024073E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 335:    1.026068E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 336:    1.033134E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 337:    1.044642E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 338:    1.052610E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 339:    1.056879E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 340:    1.064193E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 341:    1.066150E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 342:    1.071869E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 343:    1.102028E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 344:    1.105638E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 345:    1.105854E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 346:    1.107737E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 347:    1.108550E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 348:    1.109175E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 349:    1.115793E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 350:    1.127700E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 351:    1.129936E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 352:    1.132101E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 353:    1.155556E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 354:    1.156129E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 355:    1.158548E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 356:    1.162223E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 357:    1.165087E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 358:    1.173567E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 359:    1.174370E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 360:    1.182164E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 361:    1.182884E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 362:    1.186256E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 363:    1.191970E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 364:    1.192040E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 365:    1.214428E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 366:    1.214963E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 367:    1.224189E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 368:    1.227544E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 369:    1.264939E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 370:    1.269632E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 371:    1.269816E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 372:    1.276985E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 373:    1.280926E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 374:    1.286330E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 375:    1.291953E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 376:    1.295884E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 377:    1.308888E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 378:    1.313560E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 379:    1.314355E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 380:    1.323339E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 381:    1.326659E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 382:    1.340210E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 383:    1.347703E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 384:    1.352231E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 385:    1.363976E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 386:    1.367321E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 387:    1.375938E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 388:    1.385477E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 389:    1.387436E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 390:    1.389295E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 391:    1.390653E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 392:    1.392161E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 393:    1.405468E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 394:    1.406051E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 395:    1.431592E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 396:    1.431980E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 397:    1.440540E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 398:    1.456845E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 399:    1.465000E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 400:    1.465955E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: --------------------------------
ShellSolver:

Code: Select all

EigenSolve: Computed 400 Eigen Values
EigenSolve: --------------------------------
EigenSolve: 1:   -1.359819E-04   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 2:   -1.610815E-04   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 3:   -7.074813E-04   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 4:   -8.051098E-04   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 5:    2.892644E+04   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 6:    1.181673E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 7:    1.188495E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 8:    5.104661E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 9:    8.791729E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 10:    9.349423E+05   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 11:    1.265105E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 12:    1.787882E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 13:    2.518384E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 14:    3.471893E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 15:    4.923074E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 16:    5.239273E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 17:    5.787912E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 18:    6.437905E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 19:    9.127651E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 20:    9.523388E+06   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 21:    1.058571E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 22:    1.179072E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 23:    1.436553E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 24:    1.976731E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 25:    1.987186E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 26:    2.128657E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 27:    2.130777E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 28:    2.302674E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 29:    2.444527E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 30:    2.616347E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 31:    3.431836E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 32:    3.598517E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 33:    3.704607E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 34:    4.157258E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 35:    4.592975E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 36:    4.796121E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 37:    5.142518E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 38:    5.327828E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 39:    5.829838E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 40:    6.070599E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 41:    6.122833E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 42:    6.820811E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 43:    7.363545E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 44:    7.380101E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 45:    7.952497E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 46:    9.006643E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 47:    9.309413E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 48:    9.707538E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 49:    9.942038E+07   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 50:    1.108920E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 51:    1.126686E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 52:    1.206168E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 53:    1.226651E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 54:    1.238086E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 55:    1.292381E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 56:    1.354414E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 57:    1.378011E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 58:    1.424041E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 59:    1.539308E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 60:    1.602091E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 61:    1.692157E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 62:    1.900656E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 63:    1.936201E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 64:    1.978963E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 65:    1.991957E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 66:    2.070779E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 67:    2.110589E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 68:    2.119239E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 69:    2.147765E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 70:    2.273877E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 71:    2.308494E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 72:    2.528243E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 73:    2.580442E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 74:    2.683308E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 75:    2.811335E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 76:    2.833787E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 77:    2.843557E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 78:    2.900224E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 79:    2.952905E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 80:    3.243116E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 81:    3.312343E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 82:    3.391117E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 83:    3.647412E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 84:    3.681331E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 85:    3.690627E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 86:    3.730302E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 87:    3.895807E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 88:    3.959789E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 89:    4.025934E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 90:    4.081666E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 91:    4.123986E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 92:    4.221835E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 93:    4.232557E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 94:    4.645050E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 95:    4.695856E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 96:    4.862627E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 97:    4.872187E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 98:    4.936516E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 99:    5.184779E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 100:    5.309896E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 101:    5.410306E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 102:    5.714535E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 103:    5.870065E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 104:    5.913245E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 105:    5.972470E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 106:    6.019736E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 107:    6.121564E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 108:    6.263200E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 109:    6.324045E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 110:    6.384979E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 111:    6.529551E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 112:    6.572206E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 113:    6.672157E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 114:    7.141059E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 115:    7.215654E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 116:    7.244550E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 117:    7.278014E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 118:    7.788100E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 119:    7.974204E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 120:    8.022242E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 121:    8.142928E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 122:    8.236967E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 123:    8.419887E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 124:    8.557553E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 125:    8.568348E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 126:    8.830644E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 127:    9.025712E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 128:    9.220377E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 129:    9.258930E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 130:    9.546203E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 131:    9.615193E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 132:    9.975059E+08   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 133:    1.007044E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 134:    1.024687E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 135:    1.030775E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 136:    1.036784E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 137:    1.042284E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 138:    1.059952E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 139:    1.078912E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 140:    1.080250E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 141:    1.106726E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 142:    1.126361E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 143:    1.173964E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 144:    1.178776E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 145:    1.188114E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 146:    1.241515E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 147:    1.282387E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 148:    1.292819E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 149:    1.311588E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 150:    1.317627E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 151:    1.337095E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 152:    1.351571E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 153:    1.363214E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 154:    1.367740E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 155:    1.369545E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 156:    1.382529E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 157:    1.409808E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 158:    1.410438E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 159:    1.416992E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 160:    1.443795E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 161:    1.457840E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 162:    1.469902E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 163:    1.554429E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 164:    1.582475E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 165:    1.585641E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 166:    1.592292E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 167:    1.600956E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 168:    1.625416E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 169:    1.643131E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 170:    1.668143E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 171:    1.687818E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 172:    1.742937E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 173:    1.772689E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 174:    1.778853E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 175:    1.812080E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 176:    1.840433E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 177:    1.849258E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 178:    1.859815E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 179:    1.938017E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 180:    1.945501E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 181:    1.951452E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 182:    1.957861E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 183:    1.986933E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 184:    2.004457E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 185:    2.004666E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 186:    2.013359E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 187:    2.039793E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 188:    2.077232E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 189:    2.099663E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 190:    2.160274E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 191:    2.175257E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 192:    2.196568E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 193:    2.215051E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 194:    2.219568E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 195:    2.243438E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 196:    2.310651E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 197:    2.338291E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 198:    2.340439E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 199:    2.373707E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 200:    2.378272E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 201:    2.390443E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 202:    2.403567E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 203:    2.453144E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 204:    2.479381E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 205:    2.503428E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 206:    2.509039E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 207:    2.527343E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 208:    2.685021E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 209:    2.706750E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 210:    2.709165E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 211:    2.739830E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 212:    2.751041E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 213:    2.760352E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 214:    2.763955E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 215:    2.775404E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 216:    2.800288E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 217:    2.812953E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 218:    2.833184E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 219:    2.858291E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 220:    2.886434E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 221:    2.908455E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 222:    2.932836E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 223:    2.952513E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 224:    2.976783E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 225:    3.063706E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 226:    3.087431E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 227:    3.100518E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 228:    3.133662E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 229:    3.172849E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 230:    3.226273E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 231:    3.326466E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 232:    3.349177E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 233:    3.351454E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 234:    3.353618E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 235:    3.362522E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 236:    3.410555E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 237:    3.447243E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 238:    3.456124E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 239:    3.476539E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 240:    3.505733E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 241:    3.565953E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 242:    3.567936E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 243:    3.576260E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 244:    3.649616E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 245:    3.670860E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 246:    3.671543E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 247:    3.711772E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 248:    3.742452E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 249:    3.746662E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 250:    3.778320E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 251:    3.844759E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 252:    3.852599E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 253:    3.949329E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 254:    3.963008E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 255:    3.974814E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 256:    3.980012E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 257:    4.000008E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 258:    4.020399E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 259:    4.069882E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 260:    4.151958E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 261:    4.163751E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 262:    4.172882E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 263:    4.188925E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 264:    4.207358E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 265:    4.227845E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 266:    4.354616E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 267:    4.387457E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 268:    4.422539E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 269:    4.458677E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 270:    4.507355E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 271:    4.576498E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 272:    4.577312E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 273:    4.644223E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 274:    4.661157E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 275:    4.677166E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 276:    4.736486E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 277:    4.830590E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 278:    4.865638E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 279:    4.871178E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 280:    4.900949E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 281:    4.949358E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 282:    4.953790E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 283:    4.964188E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 284:    4.986470E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 285:    5.028526E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 286:    5.058027E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 287:    5.073603E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 288:    5.112573E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 289:    5.120587E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 290:    5.228519E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 291:    5.257339E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 292:    5.324505E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 293:    5.369158E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 294:    5.426384E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 295:    5.430805E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 296:    5.443682E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 297:    5.498592E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 298:    5.540155E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 299:    5.551290E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 300:    5.555697E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 301:    5.582858E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 302:    5.696191E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 303:    5.809140E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 304:    5.819629E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 305:    5.853349E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 306:    5.869473E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 307:    6.003529E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 308:    6.066564E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 309:    6.130346E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 310:    6.140714E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 311:    6.152871E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 312:    6.228207E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 313:    6.284250E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 314:    6.288882E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 315:    6.310275E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 316:    6.321607E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 317:    6.332075E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 318:    6.348356E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 319:    6.354598E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 320:    6.371458E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 321:    6.387286E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 322:    6.418186E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 323:    6.451019E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 324:    6.545312E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 325:    6.557099E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 326:    6.580844E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 327:    6.615670E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 328:    6.755717E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 329:    6.801264E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 330:    6.808151E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 331:    6.895887E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 332:    6.915916E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 333:    6.941357E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 334:    6.992523E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 335:    7.000463E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 336:    7.224517E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 337:    7.256018E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 338:    7.287261E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 339:    7.301915E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 340:    7.304970E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 341:    7.318694E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 342:    7.369928E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 343:    7.411096E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 344:    7.449464E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 345:    7.479794E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 346:    7.510372E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 347:    7.551289E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 348:    7.565400E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 349:    7.638482E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 350:    7.645693E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 351:    7.768604E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 352:    7.869110E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 353:    7.882020E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 354:    8.054780E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 355:    8.075909E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 356:    8.088538E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 357:    8.125359E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 358:    8.135548E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 359:    8.186021E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 360:    8.258646E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 361:    8.301363E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 362:    8.353233E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 363:    8.356934E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 364:    8.395697E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 365:    8.409384E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 366:    8.511966E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 367:    8.520578E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 368:    8.530269E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 369:    8.541539E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 370:    8.572502E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 371:    8.601367E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 372:    8.642277E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 373:    8.738250E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 374:    8.823151E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 375:    8.850634E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 376:    8.865861E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 377:    8.893348E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 378:    9.100906E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 379:    9.133054E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 380:    9.146164E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 381:    9.196909E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 382:    9.261227E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 383:    9.364615E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 384:    9.435158E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 385:    9.531591E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 386:    9.581807E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 387:    9.595862E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 388:    9.602295E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 389:    9.650735E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 390:    9.739899E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 391:    9.847988E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 392:    9.950567E+09   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 393:    1.002432E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 394:    1.006076E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 395:    1.007143E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 396:    1.009577E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 397:    1.015213E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 398:    1.018543E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 399:    1.026175E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: 400:    1.028025E+10   0.000000E+00
EigenSolve: --------------------------------
The sif files:

SmitcSolver:

Code: Select all

Header
  CHECK KEYWORDS Warn
  Mesh DB "." "."
  Include Path ""
  Results Directory ""
End

SimulationHeader
  CHECK KEYWORDS Warn
  Mesh DB "." "."
  Include Path ""
  Results Directory ""
End

Simulation
  Max Output Level = 5
  Coordinate System = Cartesian
  Coordinate Mapping(3) = 1 2 3
  Simulation Type = Steady state
  Steady State Max Iterations = 1
  Output Intervals = 1
  Timestepping Method = BDF
  BDF Order = 1
  Solver Input File = case.sif
  Post File = case.vtu
Coordinate Scaling = 0.001
End

Constants
  Gravity(4) = 0 -1 0 9.82
  Stefan Boltzmann = 5.67e-08
  Permittivity of Vacuum = 8.8542e-12
  Boltzmann Constant = 1.3807e-23
  Unit Charge = 1.602e-19
End

Body 1
  Target Bodies(1) = 1
  Name = "Body 1"
  Equation = 1
  Material = 1
  Body Force = 1
End

Solver 1
  Equation = Elastic Plates
  Eigen System Values = 400
  Eigen System Select = Smallest magnitude
  Procedure = "Smitc" "SmitcSolver"
  Variable = -dofs 3 Deflection
  Eigen Analysis = True
  Exec Solver = Always
  Stabilize = True
  Bubbles = False
  Lumped Mass Matrix = False
  Optimize Bandwidth = True
  Steady State Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-5
  Nonlinear System Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-7
  Nonlinear System Max Iterations = 20
  Nonlinear System Newton After Iterations = 3
  Nonlinear System Newton After Tolerance = 1.0e-3
  Nonlinear System Relaxation Factor = 1
  Linear System Solver = Direct
  Linear System Direct Method = Umfpack
End

Equation 1
  Name = "DML"
  Active Solvers(1) = 1
End

Material 1
  Name = "Aluminium (generic) - Thick"
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Damping = 4e-4
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Heat Conductivity = 237.0
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Thickness = 8.1e-4
  Heat Capacity = 897.0
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Sound speed = 5000.0
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Heat expansion Coefficient = 23.1e-6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Porosity Model = Always saturated
  Mesh Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Density = 2700.0
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
End

Body Force 1
  Name = "Damping"
  Damping = Real 4e-4
End

Boundary Condition 1
  Target Boundaries(1) = 2 
  Name = "Supported"
  Deflection 1 = 0
End
  Max Output Level = 5
  Coordinate System = Cartesian
  Coordinate Mapping(3) = 1 2 3
  Simulation Type = Steady state
  Steady State Max Iterations = 1
  Output Intervals = 1
  Timestepping Method = BDF
  BDF Order = 1
  Solver Input File = case.sif
  Post File = case.vtu
Coordinate Scaling = 0.001
End

Constants
  Gravity(4) = 0 -1 0 9.82
  Stefan Boltzmann = 5.67e-08
  Permittivity of Vacuum = 8.8542e-12
  Boltzmann Constant = 1.3807e-23
  Unit Charge = 1.602e-19
End

Solver 1
  Equation = Elastic Plates
  Eigen System Values = 400
  Eigen System Select = Smallest magnitude
  Procedure = "Smitc" "SmitcSolver"
  Variable = -dofs 3 Deflection
  Eigen Analysis = True
  Exec Solver = Always
  Stabilize = True
  Bubbles = False
  Lumped Mass Matrix = False
  Optimize Bandwidth = True
  Steady State Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-5
  Nonlinear System Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-7
  Nonlinear System Max Iterations = 20
  Nonlinear System Newton After Iterations = 3
  Nonlinear System Newton After Tolerance = 1.0e-3
  Nonlinear System Relaxation Factor = 1
  Linear System Solver = Direct
  Linear System Direct Method = Umfpack
End

Equation 1
  Name = "DML"
  Active Solvers(1) = 1
End

Material 1
  Name = "Aluminium (generic) - Thick"
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Damping = 4e-4
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Heat Conductivity = 237.0
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Thickness = 8.1e-4
  Heat Capacity = 897.0
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Sound speed = 5000.0
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Heat expansion Coefficient = 23.1e-6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Porosity Model = Always saturated
  Mesh Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Density = 2700.0
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
End

Body Force 1
  Name = "Damping"
  Damping = Real 4e-4
End

Boundary Condition 1
  Target Boundaries(4) = 1 2 3 4 
  Name = "Supported"
  Deflection 1 = 0
End
ShellSolver:

Code: Select all

Header
  CHECK KEYWORDS Warn
  Mesh DB "." "."
  Include Path ""
  Results Directory ""
End

Simulation
  Max Output Level = 5
  Coordinate System = Cartesian
  Coordinate Mapping(3) = 1 2 3
  Simulation Type = Steady state
  Steady State Max Iterations = 1
  Output Intervals = 1
  Timestepping Method = BDF
  BDF Order = 1
  Solver Input File = case.sif
  Post File = case.vtu
  Coordinate Scaling = 0.001
End

Constants
  Gravity(4) = 0 -1 0 9.82
  Stefan Boltzmann = 5.67e-08
  Permittivity of Vacuum = 8.8542e-12
  Boltzmann Constant = 1.3807e-23
  Unit Charge = 1.602e-19
End

Body 1
  Target Bodies(1) = 1
  Name = "Body 1"
  Equation = 1
  Material = 1
End

Solver 1
  Equation = ShellSolver
  Eigen System Values = 400
  Eigen System Select = Smallest magnitude
  Procedure = "ShellSolve" "ShellSolver"
  Eigen Analysis = True
  Exec Solver = Always
  Stabilize = True
  Bubbles = False
  Lumped Mass Matrix = False
  Optimize Bandwidth = True
  Steady State Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-6
  Nonlinear System Newton After Tolerance = 1.0e-7
  Nonlinear System Newton After Iterations = 20
  Nonlinear System Max Iterations = 20
  Nonlinear System Newton After Iterations = 3
  Nonlinear System Newton After Tolerance = 1.0e-3
  Nonlinear System Convergence Tolerance = 1.0e-7
  Nonlinear System Relaxation Factor = 1.0
  Linear System Solver = Direct
  Linear System Iterative Method = UmfPack
End

Equation 1
  Name = "DML"
  Active Solvers(1) = 1
End

Material 1
  Name = "Aluminium (generic) - Thick"
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Heat Conductivity = 237.0
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Thickness = 8.1e-4
  Heat Capacity = 897.0
  Youngs modulus = 70.0e9
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
  Sound speed = 5000.0
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Heat expansion Coefficient = 23.1e-6
  Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Porosity Model = Always saturated
  Mesh Poisson ratio = 0.35
  Electric Conductivity = 37.73e6
  Density = 2700.0
  Relative Permeability = 1.000022
End

Boundary Condition 1
  Target Boundaries(1) = 1 2 3 4
  Deflection 1 = Real 0
  Deflection 4 = Real 0
End
Any idea why the results differ? I have the feeling I am missing something very obvious...

Post Reply