Search found 5 matches

by Markus_eyP
05 May 2020, 18:16
Forum: ElmerGUI
Topic: [Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation
Replies: 7
Views: 5454

Re: [Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation

Thanks Kevin for your calculations, I used your sif-files (slightly adapted) for the calculations now. I'm still struggling with the problem. Attached are pictures (from ParaView) with additionally plotted lines through the center of the two magnets. The scale for the magnetic flux density Magnitude...
by Markus_eyP
20 Apr 2020, 17:04
Forum: ElmerGUI
Topic: [Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation
Replies: 7
Views: 5454

Re: [Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation

I recalculated everything and I'm still observing differences, same values as in previous posting. I'm interested in the flux density applied in y- or z- direction (perpendicular to the axes connecting the magnets). So I took "Magnetization 1" for the 2D problem (y-directionaccording to Pa...
by Markus_eyP
17 Apr 2020, 14:10
Forum: ElmerGUI
Topic: [Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation
Replies: 7
Views: 5454

[Magnetostatic] different results for 2D and 3D calculation

Hello, I'm struggling with another problem in the calculation of the magnetic flux density of two magnets. They have the same size with an edge length of 2mm and both magnets are aligned parallel on the x-axis with a distance of 1.8mm. Interestingly I got a different result for the flux in the 3D- c...
by Markus_eyP
16 Apr 2020, 16:16
Forum: ElmerGUI
Topic: [Magnetostatic] different results for FEMM and Elmer
Replies: 2
Views: 3010

Re: [Magnetostatic] different results for FEMM and Elmer

Thanks for your answer Mika. I calculated again and got different results to the previously posted ones. Too much open windows last time. :? FEMM | Elmer | H-B curve - | 457mT | linear 530mT | 517mT | non-linear So not that spectacular anymore, but some slight difference I can live with. Maybe they ...
by Markus_eyP
15 Apr 2020, 17:22
Forum: ElmerGUI
Topic: [Magnetostatic] different results for FEMM and Elmer
Replies: 2
Views: 3010

[Magnetostatic] different results for FEMM and Elmer

Hello, I try to simulate the magnetix flux density B of two parallel arranged magnets (Nd, N52). Magnetization in the same direction and perpendicular to the axis connecting both magnets . I did it with FEMM and Elmer and got different results for the strength of B. That is in the middle between bot...